Alex Salmond inquiry: Nicola Sturgeon apologises and recalls 'the moment I'll never forget'

Nicola Sturgeon has apologised to the two women who first raised complaints of sexual misconduct against Alex Salmond, and to Scottish taxpayers, for the loss of the judicial review, which saw the former first minister awarded more than £500,000 and the Scottish Government’s investigation condemned as “tainted by bias”.

In a long-awaited oral evidence session to the Holyrood committee investigating the government’s handling of the original inquiry, Ms Sturgeon said she would never forget the day Mr Salmond arrived at her house to tell her of the investigation her government was conducting into allegations against him.

And in an emotional statement, she said she had “searched” Mr Salmond’s statement to the committee last week for “any sign of regret or reflection” on his part and had found none.

Ms Sturgeon said it had been right for the government to put in place a new procedure to deal with any historic complaints of sexual harassment in the wake of the #MeToo movement.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon taking oath before giving evidence to the Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints at Holyrood in Edinburgh. Picture: Jeff J Mitchell/PA Wire

But she added: "As a result of a very serious mistake made in the investigation of the complaint, two women were failed and taxpayers’ money was lost, I deeply regret that.

“Although I wasn't aware of the error at the time, I am the head of the Scottish Government, so I want to say sorry to the two women involved and the Scottish public.”

Ms Sturgeon also said Mr Salmond’s claims of a "malicious plan” was “not based in any fact”.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon arrives to give evidence to a Scottish Parliament committee. Picture: Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images

“A number of women made complaints against Alex Salmond s behaviour, the government, despite the mistake it undoubtedly made, tried to do the right thing,” she said.

“As First Minister I tried to avoid the age old pattern of allowing a powerful man of using his status and connections to get what he wants.

“The police conducted an independent criminal investigation, the Crown Office, as it does in prosecutions every single week, considered the evidence and found there was a case to answer. A court and jury did their jobs and now this committee and an independent investigation are considering what happened and why.”

She also contradicted the claims of Mr Salmond, and those of his former counsel Duncan Hamilton QC, about the meeting at her house on April 2, 2018, that Ms Sturgeon knew what the meeting was about.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon giving evidence to the Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints, at Holyrood in Edinburgh. Picture: Jeff J Mitchell/PA Wire

"When he arrived at my house he was insistent he speak to me entirely privately, away from his former chief of staff Geoff Aberdein, Duncan Hamilton, and my chief of staff who was with me,” she said.

"That would have seemed unnecessary had there already been a shared understanding on the part of all of us.

"He then showed me a letter from the Permanent Secretary [Leslie Evans]. This set out the fact complaints had been made against him by two individuals … and set out what he was alleged to have done.

“Reading this letter is a moment in my life I will never forget.

"And although he denied the allegations, he gave me his account of one of the incidents, which he said he had apologised for at the time. What he described, constituted in my view, deeply inappropriate behaviour on his part, perhaps another reason that moment is so deeply embedded in my mind.”

Ms Sturgeon went further and said the investigation into potential breaches of the ministerial code, being conducted by James Hamilton QC, meant “he is able to see and hear material that this committee cannot, including as I understand it from people who were party to discussions that others who were not party to those discussions, are seeking to attest to”.