Letter: The thorny question of independence
If Labour honestly believes that attacking this agenda will scare voters off voting SNP, then they are obviously in a poorer state than most political commentators are claiming.
This election is about which party is best equipped to run Scotland during these very difficult economic times.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdIf Labour really believes that the issue of a referendum on independence is more important than the creation of jobs and maintaining services, then we can look for them to sink further in the opinion polls.
JIM CARSON
Larchfield
Balerno, Midlothian
When David Murray and the Scottish Sun, owned by Tory-supporting Rupert Murdoch, both declare publicly their support for Alex Salmond and the SNP while both making it clear that they do not support the establishment of an independent Scottish state which is the major - if not sole - aim of the SNP, then we are entitled to know why before 5 May.
Do they believe that the creation of an independent Scottish state is not going to happen in the foreseeable future?
Given that independence is the raison d'etre for the SNP, why do they think that?
Have they been given assurances by the SNP leadership that they will not be pressing for independence in the next five years in return for their support, despite what they say in their manifesto?
If that is the case then Mr Salmond should tell both us and, more importantly, his own supporters before the election.
JOHN MAXTON
Larch Grove
Hamilton
Your leader (25 April) points out the glaringly obvious: Labour have mentioned the most unpopular of the nationalist policies - breaking up Britain - even less than the SNP. It seems that the Labour have been so reluctant to mention the "I" word.
Some years ago Labour ran a most successful ''Divorce is Expensive'' campaign that simply reminded voters of the consequences of voting for a party dedicated to breaking up the UK and withdrawing Scotland from Nato. The SNP hated it as it told the truth. This should be resurrected while there is still time.
ALEXANDER McKAY
New Cut Rigg
Edinburgh
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdIain Gray recognises that "the Greens are right about so much", but not about whether there should be a referendum on Scotland's relationship with the UK, depending on the outcome of the Scottish election.
But the question of a referendum is not about independence - it is about democracy; about letting the people of Scotland have the ultimate say. If they say "No" to independence, as Iain Gray would clearly wish, then that puts it to bed for the foreseeable future.
Leave the question unasked and it is forever the elephant in the parliamentary chamber.
That, doubtless, is why the Liberal Democrats appear much more relaxed about a referendum now as well; and indeed why Labour, under Wendy Alexander, briefly came down on the side of democracy as well.
GAVIN CORBETT
Briarbank Terrace
Edinburgh
May 5 could be the day that all the major political parties in Scotland come to terms with the relentless march of Scotland to a very different constitutional future and redefine their attitude on this issue. It is entirely possible to be a socialist, a Tory, a Liberal or a supporter of the Labour Party and, at the same time, a nationalist.
DAVID McEWAN HILL
Tom Nan Ragh
Dalinlongart, Argyll